
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
Bruce Cockburn Sings In the Shack

Objective Truth & the "W-Word"

In my MCCC Logic classes I tell the students that, in philosophy, "logic" is about:
- 1. evaluating arguments
- 2. arguments are composed of statements (or propositions)
- 3. a "statement" is a sentence that is either true or false 4. an argument has only one conclusion
- an argument has one or more premises 5. for an argument to establish (either deductively or inductively) the truth of the conclusion, there must be a "claim of inference" from the premise(s) to the conclusion. That's the "logic" part of logic.
- 6. then, if the premises are true, the conclusion follows either deductively (necessarily) or inductively (probably)
Here's where the trouble begins. My use of the 'w' word ("wrong") strikes a chord of offensiveness. For some of my students it is wrong to say that anyone else is wrong. W-language comes from another planet. The w-word marginalizes people into two groups, and that's wrong to do. On the planet where some of my students live it is wrong to say anyone is wrong because they might not be wrong and how could someone ever know for sure that another person is wrong and maybe I am wrong about the other person being wrong and besides telling someone "You are wrong" is so very, very wrong. My experience, on the other hand and from the POV of the planet I live on, is that when I say (3) above, and use the words "So if you were to think that the statement The lights in this room are now on is false when, objectively, they are on, then you would be... wrong."
Every semester I have students who cannot bear to hear that. They think I am arrogant to call someone else wrong. They think I am wrong to do such things, and some of them walk me to the parking lot letting me know how very wrong I am to talk like that. When I try to tell them that they are using the w-word against me, it is as if they are placed in a position above me and thus can use the w-word in a non-offensive way to let me know how offended they are. Logically, I get ad-hominized.This kind of response happens within the minds of some, not all, students. Yet it seems to be a moment of stunning revelation to a number of them to hear a professor utter words like "true" and "false."
Welcome to the world of philosophical logic, which caters not at all to human felings and desires. It is only after truth. Truth is a function of statements. Statements are sentences that are either true or false. You have just finished reading this. Arguably, that is true.Monday, October 19, 2009
Drawing Close to God This Week

(*Dim Sum, in New York City. Nov. 2008)
Here's what I'm doing this week to enter into greater intimacy with the Triune God.
- Setting aside time for just me and God- Praying “Draw Me Closer, Lord”
- Reading & meditating on John chapters 14-17
- Listening – when God speaks to me I’ll write it in my journal
- Obeying (“If you love me obey my commands”)
- Welcoming the Holy Spirit into my spiritual house (i.e., my heart)
* literally, "touch the heart"
Witherington's Withering Critique of Pagan Christianity

Friday, October 16, 2009
Preaching This Sunday On...

Kenneth Miller on Why Evolutionary Theory Does Not Explain All of Reality

First, some do claim this. Those who do are, usually, evolutionary naturalists. That is, they espouse a form of philosophical naturalism, or physicalism, that states that matter is all there is; there are no non-material realities.
Second, theistic evolutionary theorists such as, e.g., Brown University biologist Kenneth Miller, affirm evolutionary theory but not as explanatory of all reality. Here, e.g., is Miller, in his debate with atheist Christopher Hitchens. After Hitchens sets up a caricature of "faith" and demolishes his straw man, Miller responds:
"In the end you have no answer to why science works, why the physical logic of natural law makes life possible, or why the human mind is able to explore and understand nature. And I agree that there is no scientific answer to such questions. That is precisely the point of faith–to order and rationalize our encounters with the world around us. Faith is human, and therefore imperfect. But faith expresses, however poorly, a reality that includes the scientific experience in every sense, and therefore has become more relevant than ever in our scientific age." (Emphasis mine.)
Here Miller expresses a point that is often made and hugely discussed by philosophers and scientists who ask the meta-questions like "Why does science work at all?" Miller understands that science, qua science, cannot answer this kind of question. Miller the theist admits of realities that evolutionary theory, as wonderful as it is in explaining aspects of physical reality, cannot explain because these realities are not of the kind to be scientically explained.
Here is Miller in his NOVA interview:
Q: Does science have limits to what it can tell us?
Miller: If science is competent at anything, it's in investigating the natural and material world around us. What science isn't very good at is answering questions that also matter to us in a big way, such as the meaning, value, and purpose of things. Science is silent on those issues. There are a whole host of philosophical and moral questions that are important to us as human beings for which we have to make up our minds using a method outside of science. (Emphasis mine.)
So Miller the theist evolutionary theorist agrees there are limits to what science can tell us. I think he is correct. So evolutionary theory does not explain "all of reality."
Thursday, October 15, 2009
Being Like a Child Does Not Mean Perpetual Intellectual Toddlerhood

(Manhattan, Nov. 2008)
In Matthew 18:3 Jesus says, "I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven." Part of this is one of those upside-down-kingdom things, since children approached to lower levels of human expendability. To understand Jesus one must give up all self-pretension and all self-aggrandization. It's instructive to note that this does not mean that one remains, mentally, as a toddler.
C.S. Lewis, in Mere Christianity, writes:
"Because Christ said we could only get into His world by being like children, many Christians have the idea that, provided you are 'good', it does not matter being a fool... Christ never meant that we were to remain children in intelligence: on the contrary. He told us to be not only 'as harmless as doves', but also 'as wise as serpents'. He wants a child's heart, but a grown-up's head."
Tuesday, October 13, 2009
The Flaw in Richard Dawkins's "Greatest Show on Earth"

"Air-Guitar" Religion

Saturday, October 10, 2009
Preaching Tomorrow on...

...John 14:8-11
“Jesus manifests God’s presence and work through his signs and in his words.” (Marianne Meye, The God of the Gospel of John, 233)
“The story of God’s “indwelling” in ancient Israel is taken up and extended in the Gospel of John. The Gospel does not merely use the language of indwelling, but of mutual indwelling or mutual immanence, and does so in an extensive way.” (Jurgen Moltmann, “God in the World – the World in God: Perichoresis in
Trinity and Eschatology,” in Richard Bauckham and Carl Mosser, The Gospel of John and Christian Theology, 372)
“What is at stake here is nothing less than Jesus’ ability to provide firsthand revelation of God (cf. 1:18).” (Andreas Kostenberger, John, 431)
(Andrew "Rublev’s icon gives us a glimpse of the house of perfect love” -Henri Nouwen)