Tuesday, May 09, 2017
Bono: 3 Questions in 46 Seconds on the Psalms
NOTE: The Fuller Studio (Fuller Theological Seminary) is producing amazing resources for pastoral and academic ministry.
Thursday, May 04, 2017
The Irrelevancy of Many Church Meetings (The Presence-Driven Church)
![]() |
| Our garage, on a cold night |
Have you ever been in a church meeting where the only outcome was deciding when to meet again? I have. I have actually led some of them.
Sometimes it is good to just be together. But church meetings are usually scheduled for more than, "Hey, let's hang out at the church building next week!"
Some people need to have meetings to validate their leadership. This is like a pastor who reasons, "I need to be in my office in the church building, doing something, doing anything, even if no one else is there." (One time someone in my church saw me in the grocery store, on a Wednesday morning. They called some of our church leaders and reported me.)
Thomas Merton, in New Seeds of Contemplation, writes:
"There are men dedicated to God whose lives are full of restlessness and who have no real desire to be alone. Interior solitude is impossible for them. They fear it. They do everything they can to escape it. What is worse, they try to draw everyone else into activities as senseless and as devouring as their own. They are great promoters of useless work. They love to organize meetings and banquets and conferences and lectures. They print circulars, write letters, talk for hours on the telephone in order that they might gather a hundred people in a large room where they will all fill the air with smoke and make a great deal of noise and roar at one another and clap their hands and stagger home at last, patting one another on the back with the assurance that they have all done great things to spread the Kingdom of God."
In a Presence-Driven Church, are there meetings. Of course! The bottom line is: does God want us to have a meeting? If so, then meet. If not, then don't. Another meeting just for the sake of having a meeting has an illogical circularity about it that creates corporate nothingness.
Tuesday, May 02, 2017
Is Religion Inherently Violent?
![]() |
| Monroe County |
Is religion inherently violent? Are religious people more violent than non-religious people? I don't think so. For many of us, myself included, our faith in God and following after Jesus has worked to purge violence out of us. (Still more to come...)
Is atheism inherently violent? I think so. Since if one follows the logic of atheism-as-metaphysical-naturalism, then morality doesn't even exist. As Nietzsche the atheist knew, humans invent morality for their own self-preservation. It is important to know that the greatest moral atrocities of the last century were perpetrated by atheists - see here.
On atheism-as-naturalism there is no place for human free will. To acknowledge this provides incentive for bad behavior. Alfred Mele writes:
"There’s evidence that lowering people’s confidence in the existence of free will increases bad behavior. In one study (Vohs and Schooler 2008), people who read passages in which scientists deny that free will exists are more likely to cheat on a subsequent task. In another experiment (Baumeister et al. 2009), college students presented with a series of sentences denying the existence of free will proceeded to behave more aggressively than a control group: they served larger amounts of spicy salsa to people who said they dislike spicy food, despite being told these people had to eat everything on their plates." (Mele, Free: Why Science Hasn't Disproved Free Will, pp. 4-5. Oxford University Press.)
Growing up, I was not an especially violent child. I didn't get into fights. I've only hit someone once, when I was about eight years old. I hit a kid who was bullying me. I didn't hurt him. But he hurt me, having hit me very hard.
Why are religious people portrayed by some as inherently violent? Miroslav Volf calls this "the self-inflation of the negative, the tendency of the evil to loom larger than the comparatively much more prevalent good." (Volf, A Public Faith, Kindle Locations 946-947) It only takes one cockroach in your food to turn a delicious meal into an abomination. Our media frenzy-feeds off violence and evil. One televangelist who steals people's money spoils them all, in the eyes of irrational people.
Volf writes:
"One can easily show that the majority of Christians (and the majority of religious folks in general) are nonviolent citizens, peace lovers, peacemakers, some even peace activists—and are such precisely out of religious reasons. The purveyors of violence who seek religious legitimation are statistically a small minority among Christians (as they are among other religions as well)." (Ib., Kindle Locations 939-942)
My experience with a few thousand Christian leaders over the past 40 years, as I have been privileged to instruct them and read their spiritual journals, shows me that the vast majority of them are not in ministry to make money; are great servants of other people; are in touch with the violence and rubbish in their own souls; and pray for increased love and compassion towards others.
None of us are perfect. Those of us who follow Jesus are influenced by his nonviolent alternative. To follow Jesus is to have the human heart transformed from violence into peace.
Monday, May 01, 2017
Will Self-Driving Cars Be Able to Make Moral Decisions?
![]() |
| Bangkok |
Johnathan Merritt discusses this in "Is AI a Threat to Christianity?"
See Larry Greenemeier, "Driverless Cars Will Face Moral Dilemmas."
See Jean-Francois Bonnefon, et. al., "The Social Dilemma of Autonomous Vehicles."
Study what is probably the most famous philosophical ethical dilemma - "The Trolley Problem," by Judith Jarvis Thomson. I introduce my logic students to this. For further reading, see Would You Kill the Fat Man? The Trolley Problem and What Your Answer Tells Us About Right and Wrong.
Self-administer the "trolley problem" dilemma at M.I.T.'s Moral Machine website. Ask yourself - could a self-driving car do this?
See Harvard neuroscientist Joshua Greene, "Our Driverless Dilemma: "When Should Your Car Be Willing to Kill You?"
For great stuff on the Christian idea of a human soul, see J. P. Moreland, The Soul: How We Know It's Real and Why It Matters.
I am still reading through the short essays in What to Think About Machines That Think: Today's Leading Thinkers on the Age of Machine Intelligence. Various scholars share their views on the threat of A.I., and whether or not a machine could have self-consciousness, or have a soul.
See Gordon-Conwell theologian Russell Bjork, "Artificial Intelligence and the Soul."
Saturday, April 29, 2017
Happiness Is a Negative Goal of Entitlement
![]() |
| Trees in my backyard |
I recommend John Townsend's The Entitlement Cure to every troubled person (such as I) who helps other troubled people.
"Entitlement" is "the belief that I am exempt from responsibility and I am owed special treatment. Entitlement is: The man who thinks he is above all the rules. The woman who feels mistreated and needs others to make it up to her.” (p. 19).
Townsend says there are two negative fruits of entitlement. The first is: An attitude of entitlement will limit your goals. Entitlement thinking misconstrues the goal of life to be "happiness." Like: "I want to be happy, that's all." Entitlement people view the highest good in life as being a happy person. This, writes Townsend, "is one of the worst endgame goals we can have." (66)
Townsend states:
"People who have happiness as their goal get locked into the pain/ pleasure motivation cycle. They never do what causes them pain, but always do what brings them pleasure. This puts us on the same thinking level as a child, who has difficulty seeing past his or her fear of pain and love of pleasure." (Ib.)
The root of this idea developed in the soil of Jeremy Bentham's utilitarianism (see William Davies, The Happiness Industry). This is secularism's puerile substitute for objective moral values.
"There is nothing wrong with happiness. But in a healthy life, happiness comes as a by-product of doing what you love, having purpose, and giving back. You don’t give your talents so that you’ll be happy; you give them because you care and you want to make a difference. Then you feel happy. Happiness is a by-product to enjoy, not a dream to seize." (Townsend, pp. 66-67)
The second negative fruit of entitlement is: "it freezes development." God made us to discover and develop a variety of abilities and passions. But "entitlement influences us to stay right where we are. It keeps us from growing, learning, challenging ourselves, or trying new things. It whispers to us, “That sounds really hard and it doesn’t look like it’s worth it.”" (Ib., 67)
This voice will put us to sleep. "We might become couch potatoes, video addicts, chronic partiers, or simply get in a rut and routine that becomes boring and deadening." (Ib.)
When we understand who we are and what we are here for, and then live out of our true identity and God's purposes for us, we will experience joy as a fruit, as a wonderful byproduct of the Spirit in us.
***
SEE ALSO:
Entitlement People Find Eternal Separation From God Reprehensible
Wednesday, April 26, 2017
Dinner and Auction to Support Mary Robey Koch
(Written by Mike Ansel)
Scripture says to mourn with those who mourn and to rejoice with those who rejoice. As people, and especially as a group of Christian (Called out ones) people, our hearts are drawn to this sister who has been through more than we can imagine or even phantom!
Mary Robey Koch entered the hospital with the hope of delivering her first child and the joy this would bring her and her husband. After delivering her healthy son Cooper Mary contacted Sepsis and was thrown into a fight for her life! Her extremities were under attack and within two days of delivery her feet and lower calf were amputated. Muscle and infected dead skin were also removed as the doctors at the University of Michigan raced to save her hands! Prayer warriors were called upon to stand in the gap for Mary. It was not to be so as two days after loosing her feet Mary lost her hands! Unimaginable nightmare for this young first time mother, her mom and dad, and her inlaws!
Mary spent seven months in the trauma burn unit at the U. of M. hospital, and has been home for a month now. Mary has a long road ahead of her with therapy, prosthetics, Dr. appointments, and caring for her now 8 month old son! Of course Mary has had her "down" moments, but her faith remains strong as she puts her spiritual hands to the plow and moves forward with grace, strength, and dignity! Mary has had a lot of support from her family and friends, and that's where we come in at Redeemer Fellowship. We believe in the Church as the wider body of those who have been saved and sanctified by the sacrifice of Jesus. Mary is a fellow sojourner on this road leading to the Celestial City. It is our Christian honor to help her along the way!
Mary and her family have many needs, and one of the most pressing is monetary. We (at Redeemer) are planning a Dinner/Auction in order to raise funds toward those needs. I (we) want to partner with this sister and her family in a show of Christian unity and support.
Of course we welcome help from all people of good will and compassion toward this cause.
The time is fast approaching when we will collectively bring forth a sacrifice of praise as we fellowship around a meal and auction/fundraiser in support of Mary at Redeemer Fellowship Church in Monroe.
The date is May 13th. with auction viewing at 4:00 p.m. and dinner at 5:00 p.m. Live auction to start after dinner. Silent auction bidding will start upon your arrival. Two separate dinners will be served. The wild game dinner is $15.00 dollars for adults 13 and up and $8.00 dollars for those 12 and under. 4 and under free! The alternative dinner will be a simple hot dog, sloppy Joe, potato chips, dessert, and drink dinner for $6.00 for adults and $4.00 for children 12 and under.
In order to have a smooth operation it would be so helpful if we can have a "head" count as to who will be attending so the proper amount of food can be prepared. Auction items are still being accepted, as well as desserts, or a special "wild game" dish you would like to prepare!
Monetary donations are also greatly appreciated. Call Mike Ansel at 734-241-3329 home or 734-770-4660 for information. Lets make this day before Mothers Day a time of rejoicing for Mary and her supporters!
Email Mike Ansel at - mikewansel@yahoo.com
Email John Piippo at - johnpiippo@msn.com
Tuesday, April 25, 2017
Dr. Seuss's Cartesian, Sartrean Birthday Philosophy
One of my favorite birthday books is Dr. Seuss’s epic Happy Birthday to You. For many years I read it to my sons on their birthdays. This has stopped, since they are now in their thirties.
Happy Birthday to You (hereafter HBtY) is the story of the Birthday Bird (hereafter BB) from the land of Katroo (hereafter Katroo), who arrives one night at the bedside of a boy on the eve of the boy’s birthday. The BB sweeps the kid up and takes him to Katroo for the hugest sugar-carb-filled birthday ever seen.
Seuss writes, on the BB:
“Katroo is the only place Birthday Birds grow.
This bird has a brain. He's the most beautifully brained
With the brainiest bird-brain that's ever been trained.
He was trained by the most splendid Club in this nation,
The Katroo Happy Birthday Asso-see-eye-ation.”
Even though Seuss does some loopy question-begging here, we see that the BB is smart. How smart? The BB has the “brainiest bird-brain that’s ever been trained.”
The word “brainiest” is a superlative, indicating incomparability. The BB has (thinking on Anselmian lines) “a brain a greater than which cannot be conceived.” If it is the “brainiest” bird brain, indicating a brain a greater than which cannot be conceived, then the BB has omniscience. The BB seems to be, like God, an omniscient being.
The BB’s brain is “beautiful.” Like Nobel Laureate John Nash, the BB has “a beautiful mind.” Here one does not mean the brain’s physicality, but its sheer cognitive mental powers. But if the BB’s brain was “trained,” does that not imply that the brain-trainers of the Katroo Happy Birthday Asso-see-eye-ation have brainier brains than the brainiest brain of the BB? An omniscient brain would not require training. So on this point Seuss is logically incoherent.
"Dr." Seuss made his living on logical incoherencies. But that fact should not cause one to dismiss what comes next. To do so would be to miss some of the best philosophizing in all of Western culture.
“He [the BB] knows your address, and he heads for your bed.
You hear a soft swoosh in the brightening sky.
You are not all awake. But you open one eye.
Then over the housetops and trees of Katroo,
You see that bird coming! To you. Just to you!
That Bird pops right in! You are up on your feet!”
This is troublesome. A total stranger who:
1) Knows your address? How did the BB know your address? Because an omniscient being knows all things that can possibly be known, which would include your address.
2) The BB “pops right in.”
3) The BB “heads for your bed.”
This is disconcerting. The boy does not know the BB. He does not know the BB is omniscient. Even if he did know that the BB is omniscient, this does not imply that the BB is omnibenevolent. As far as the boy knows, the BB may be malevolent. Here is an omniscient and possibly malevolent Bird popping into your room, and heading for your bed. This is the stuff of nightmares.
The BB says to the boy, “Get dressed!” This is an abduction. He sweeps the boy away, and on to Katroo!
Five minutes later, you're having a snack
On you way out of town on a Smorgasbord's back.
"Today," laughs the Bird, "eat whatever you want.
Today no one tells you you cawnt or you shawnt.
And, today, you don't have to be tidy or neat.
If you wish, you may eat with both hands and both feet.
So get in there and munch. Have a big munch-er-oo!
Today is your birthday! Today you are you!
My concerns and thoughts include:
• The use of ‘cawnt’ and ‘shawnt’ are typical Seuss-isms as he desperately keeps the rhyme going.
• The assumption is: on your birthday, no one has the right to tell you what you can or cannot do. I like this, since today is my birthday.
• All food groups and food non-groups are fair game on your birthday. I like this, since today is my birthday.
• Forget all sanitary rules. I don't like this.
• Even eat with hands and both feet. The thought of eating with both feet disturbs me. Especially since, at my age, I can barely touch my feet.
• On your birthday you can eat like a pig with its snout everlastingly nuzzling in the trough of all calories.
Now Seuss engages in some big-time philosophizing. He writes:
“Today is your birthday. Today you are you!”
You are you. ‘A’ is ‘A.’ This is the logic of identity. It’s tautological thinking, redundant stuff, Kantian analytic predicating. Leibnizian "identity of indiscernibles." When the subject is the self and the predicate is also the self we have a powerful, existential statement of personal identity. We are now heading in two converging directions; viz., Cartesianism and Kierkegaard’s idea of truth as subjectivity. Let us proceed.
“If we didn't have birthdays, you wouldn't be you.
If you'd never been born, well then what would you do?
If you'd never been born, well then what would you be?
You might be a fish! Or a toad in a tree!
You might be a doorknob! Or three baked potatoes!
You might be a bag full of hard green tomatoes.
Or worse than all that… Why, you might be a WASN'T!
A Wasn't has no fun at all. No, he doesn't.
A Wasn't just isn't. He just isn't present.
But you… You ARE YOU! And, now isn't that pleasant!”
Seuss sets before us a philosophical smorgasbord. There are so many choices here that one wonders where to begin!
1. “If you’d never been born, then what would you do?” The answer is, ‘you’ wouldn’t ‘do’ anything, since ‘you’ would not be. "You" would not even be a "nonexistent thing," as if nonexistence could be predicated of nothing. ("Nonexistent thing" is a contradiction.)
2. You might be “a toad in a tree.” But this cannot be true, since if ‘you’ had never been born, then ‘you’ would not have been born as a toad in a tree. Had you been born as a toad in a tree you would have been born, and thus be a "you," but you would not know it. We have toads croaking in our backyard as I write. Perhaps some of them are in trees. Not one of them is thinking, “Wow – I was born as a toad in a tree!”
3. You could never have been born as a doorknob. No current physical theory allows for that kind of thing to happen. Doorknobs cannot procreate.
4. But… you might be a “Wasn’t.” That is, if you had never been born, even as a toad in a tree (but not as a doorknob) you would not exist at all and would be, ipso facto, a ‘Wasn’t.’
Pause here for a moment. I now compare Jean Paul Sartre’s Being and Nothingness with Seussian philosophy.
In the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy essay on “Sartre’s Existentialism” we read:
“Sartre’s ontology is explained in his philosophical masterpiece, Being and Nothingness, where he defines two types of reality which lie beyond our conscious experience: the being of the object of consciousness and that of consciousness itself. The object of consciousness exists as “in-itself,” that is, in an independent and non-relational way. However, consciousness is always consciousness “of something,” so it is defined in relation to something else, and it is not possible to grasp it within a conscious experience: it exists as “for-itself.” An essential feature of consciousness is its negative power, by which we can experience “nothingness.” This power is also at work within the self, where it creates an intrinsic lack of self-identity. So the unity of the self is understood as a task for the for-itself rather than as a given.”
The connections between Sartre and Seuss should be obvious. But just in case they are not:
1. Seuss’s “You are you” (or later, his “I am I”) is “independent and non-relational.” Here, the Seussian self is not defined in relation to something else. It exists “for itself.” This is precisely the kind of birthday Seuss is advocating; viz., a birthday that is only about the self and for the self. I like this because today is my birthday.
2. A ‘Wasn’t’ has an “intrinsic lack of self-identity.” That is, a ‘Wasn’t’ essentially, or ontologically, lacks self-identity.
The philosophical excitement builds as Seuss writes:
“Shout loud at the top of your voice, "I AM I!
ME!
I am I!
And I may not know why
But I know that I like it.
Three cheers! I AM I!"”
Sartre’s definition of existentialism is: existence precedes essence. One first of all, primordially, exists. “I am .” Or: ‘A’ is ‘A.’ The predicate is self-identical with the subject. One’s existence is, drawing from Kant, “analytic” rather than “synthetic.”
Seuss continues:
“Sing loud, "I am lucky!" Sing loud, "I am I!"
If you'd never been born, then you might be an ISN'T!
An Isn't has no fun at all. No he disn't.
He never has birthdays, and that isn't pleasant.
You have to be born, or you don't get a present.”
Here a celebration breaks forth as the Cartesian certainty is clarified. I exist! Seuss’s Cartesian certainty is as follows:
1. I have a birthday.
2. Therefore I am.
You have to exist to have a birthday. Neither Seuss nor Descartes nor Sartre are making an evidentialist argument for personal existence. One’s own existence is simply a given, a datum, much like a Plantingian “properly basic belief.” (Note: you have to exist in order to utter the proposition "I have a birthday." Claim-making requires actual existence.)
Which brings us to my favoritest line in the entire book:
“You have to be born, or you don’t get a present.”
Taking this line, and using a reductio, I reason:
1. I got presents today.
2. Therefore I was born.
3. Therefore I exist. (From 1 & 2)
The rest of Seuss’s book is a giant celebration of ego-centered, non-relational, personal, gluttonous existence. At the book’s end I am exhausted and touched, as Seuss writes:
“I am what I am! That's a great thing to be!
If I say so myself, HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME!"
Now, by Horseback and bird-back and Hiffer-back, too,
Come your friends! All your friends! From all over Katroo!
And the Birthday Pal-alace heats up with hot friends
And your party goes on!
On and on
Till it ends.
When it ends,
You're much happier,
Richer and fatter.
And the Bird flies you home
On a very soft platter.
So that's
What the Birthday Bird
Does in Katroo.
And I wish
I could do
All these great things for you!”
Saturday, April 22, 2017
The True Contrarians of Our Time
![]() |
| Bangkok |
Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. This is called Newton's third law of physics.
America's current over-sexed reaction is already causing a reaction. There is, Mary Eberstadt says, an itinerant but continuous exodus out of non-religious territories and into religious ones is ecumenical—neither just a Catholic nor a Protestant thing.
Eberstadt quotes Russell Moore's observation in his 2015 book Onward: Engaging the Culture without Losing the Gospel,
"The sexual revolution cannot keep its promises. People think they want autonomy and transgression, but what they really want is fidelity and complementarity and incarnational love. If that’s true, then we will see a wave of refugees from the sexual revolution."
Eberstadt writes:
"We’re already seeing it. These are the true contrarians of our time—the believers who do not want to jettison the Judeo-Christian moral code, but want to do something more radical: namely, live by it."
Eberstadt, Mary. It's Dangerous to Believe: Religious Freedom and Its Enemies (pp. 114-115). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.
Thursday, April 20, 2017
Good Night, Modus Ponens
I've taught Logic at Monroe County Community College for seventeen years. I've decided not to teach it anymore. Next fall I'll teach one class - Philosophy of Religion. That is my great love. Understanding logic undergirds everything in it.
I am thankful to Bill McCloskey and John Holladay for inviting me to teach logic. Seventeen years of doing this has, hopefully, strengthened my logic chops.
Tonight was my last teaching class. Next Tuesday I'll give the last exam.
So...
Good night, modus ponens
Good night, modus tollens
Good night, Bayes' Theorem
Good night, hypothetical syllogism
Good night, genetic fallacy
Good night, begging the question
Good night, constructive dilemma
Good night, false dilemma
Good night, tu quoque
Good night, equivocation
Good night, soundness
Good night, validity
Good night, induction
Good night, deduction
Good night, negating the consequent
Good night, affirming the antecedent
Good night, subjectivist fallacy
Good night, emotivist ethics
Good night, logic students
Good night, logic text
Tuesday, April 18, 2017
Honor in the Real Church
![]() |
| Weko Beach, Michigan |
Someone in my church asked me to say some things about "honor." So here are a few ideas.
Honor is respect for other people. This does not mean you agree with everything other people say. Honor is a way of treating other people. Remember that Jesus said "Honor your father and mother." (Matthew 15:4) He does not add, "only if you agree with them about everything." 1 Peter 2:7 says, "Show proper respect to everyone, love the family of believers, fear God, honor the emperor." (Even the emperor? Think about it. Do not get your ethics from the media.)
Honor thinks of other people before it thinks of oneself. Romans 12:10 says, "Be devoted to one another in love. Honor one another above yourselves."
Honor thinks of other people before it thinks of oneself. Romans 12:10 says, "Be devoted to one another in love. Honor one another above yourselves."
Honor dignifies others. Honor does not talk negatively about people behind their back. That's called slander. Or gossip. Slander is saying something about a person behind their back that you would never say to their face.
Honor is different from flattery or sucking up to people, which are forms of dishonor. Flattery is saying something to someone's face that you would never say about them behind their back.
Honor does not gripe or complain about other people behind their back. To do that is to take what John Bevere called "the bait of Satan," and dangle Satan's bait before the ears of others.
Honor is different from flattery or sucking up to people, which are forms of dishonor. Flattery is saying something to someone's face that you would never say about them behind their back.
Honor does not gripe or complain about other people behind their back. To do that is to take what John Bevere called "the bait of Satan," and dangle Satan's bait before the ears of others.
Honor listens. Honor has "ears to hear."
Honor is a subcategory of love. Love is the great umbrella, beneath which honor is one of love's expressions. Honor is one way of expressing love.
Honor does not discriminate.
Honor does not enable the transgressions of others. Enabling people in their failure is dishonoring.
Dishonor is disrespect. Dishonor disses others; honor elevates others.
Dishonor judges before understanding. Honor works to understand before evaluating or judging. Judging before understanding is the game of fools; understanding before judging is wisdom.
Dishonor judges before understanding. Honor works to understand before evaluating or judging. Judging before understanding is the game of fools; understanding before judging is wisdom.
A culture of honor extends to isolated people. Dishonor plays favorites.
Honor-able people are people capable of treating others according to their true identities, as sons and daughters of God.
Real Church cultivates an honor culture. We may not agree with everything and everyone, but we never dishonor one another.
Real Church cultivates an honor culture. We may not agree with everything and everyone, but we never dishonor one another.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









